Then it Dawned on Me Ch. 06 - Sex Stories

Then it Dawned on Me Ch. 06

... along."

I didnt hear anything she said after that. My neck broke into a cold sweat, my face got hot, and a tickle in the back of my throat that usually meant I was about to cry, muted me. My body went through the motions of nodding along and making follow-up appointments, and getting in the car, all the while my brain was screaming "Oh, fuck. Oh, fuck. Oh, fuck."

I got behind the wheel, shut my door and burst into tears. Why? Why was I about to have to deliver the best news to my husband with the absolute biggest caveat.

Me: Meet me at home when you're done with your call.

Matt: On my way.

"Hey honey, how'd it go at the doctor?"

"I'm pregnant."

"What!? Oh my god. Jane! That's amazing!"

"Sort of."

"What the hell do you mean sort of!? It's everything we wanted. We thought you couldn't. It's a miracle."

"I'm five weeks. Do you know what was five weeks ago?"

His brow furrowed, and he shook his head like he was annoyed with this little quiz until it dawned on him. His eyes widened and his jaw hung open. "Ffuuuccckkk."

"Yeah... My birthday." The date of our absolutely unforgettable, incestuous, double creampie, threesome with my brother.

"It could be his..." he said quietly as he rubbed his brow in disbelief and started to pace.

"Or yours... It'll be a while until we can find out."

"Have you been with him since?" He stopped and stared at me.

"No. I promised I would tell you when we had sex again." After our threesome Matt told me he ...

... was okay with Ethan and me fucking, on occasion, as long as I told him about it or included him.

He ran his hands over his face and stopped covering his mouth. I felt his dread and disappointment.

"Did you know?" He asked.

"Know what?"

"Did you know you were ovulating when you asked if he could cum inside you?" He asked raising his voice at me.

"Matt! How could you ask me that?"

"You used to know every single time."

"Yeah, when we were trying to have a baby. When we stopped trying, I stopped keeping track. It was just depressing. I thought I couldn't... I wasn't trying to... I wouldn't..." I was really having trouble keeping my composure. I was cracking and he could see.

"Honey, shhh... I'm sorry. You couldn't have known... Besides, the threesome was my idea, and I all but told him to cum inside you. We both didn't think it was possible." He sat down and invited me over with him. He looked pained and I got close but stayed away knowing I was the cause. "I'm sorry for what I said, and for yelling. I know the doctor said it was possible that you couldn't, but I've felt insecure that it's me that couldn't give you a baby. I thought maybe you thought the same and wanted to try with him, but it's just my insecurity. I don't think you would do that. This isn't ideal, but... It doesn't matter.. We're having a baby, right?" he said holding me as I cried. He stroked my hair and kissed the top of my head. "As long as it's healthy, I don't care. That's my baby. We ...