Cheat Day - Sex Stories

Cheat Day

... to get more used to that kind of stuff, or something. If you wanted. I dunno. It’s stupid. Sorry.” John got up and started to walk in a random direction.

“Wait, John, stop!” Jake said with urgency.

“Let him go,” Katie urged. “If he needs t-”

“No, that’s just a locked door is all,” Jake said at the same time as John turned the knob and walked right into the door. At once, all four of us started laughing, albeit a bit nervously.

“Sorry,” John said again.

“Nothing to be sorry for,” Jake said, cool as a cucumber. “I’ve never gotten an offer like this-”

“It wasn’t an offer you smoothbrain, you threatened to whip it out,” Katie interrupted.

“Yeah well… I dunno. Maybe it could be fun,” Jake continued, watching John slowly walk back towards the couch.

How the hell did we get here?! I didn’t even like dick. Why was this offer even on the table? I wanted to protest, but I knew that if I protested and gave that as my reason, Jake would just throw the “oh, why are

you

making it sexual” thing back in my face. If I said I didn’t want to see his dick, I knew he’d spin it into me not

wanting

to see his dick, and he’d make it about want. Hell, I was very sure I was straight…

…I looked back at John. Keyword,

was

. I knew for a long time that I was straight because I was not into dick, but there was something about John that was… cute. The way he was kind of timid, but still got out there and got a word in. He wasn’t just a stereotypical shy ...

... person, he still tried. He had these cute little mannerisms, like narrowing his eyes mid-thought or cocking his head randomly. Plus, he didn’t have a dick, and that was my main gripe.

So… so maybe, I was into… Man, I didn’t know. Did I have to know?

“Ethan? Last chance to complain,” Jake teased. “Maybe I can angle it away from you.”

I shook my head. “Wait, are you actually doing this?”

“Well, she did just dare me,” Jake admitted.

“Dare? When did she dare? She didn’t dare,” I protested.

Silence. Silence filled the room. I looked at the movie. It was paused. “You really were off in La-La Land for a bit, weren’t you?” Katie laughed. “Yeah, I just dared him. You just didn’t notice.”

“But… won’t this impact our friendship or something?” I asked worriedly.

Katie shrugged. “Jake insists it won’t. And even if it does, we’ll just talk it out like adults. Besides, John seems kinda…” She trailed off, looking at John.

“Yeah. Could be fun,” John breathed excitedly. I turned to him and he gave me one of his cute little smiles.

Why did I open the Pandora’s Box of thinking John was cute? Now his little smile made me more excited. My heart was getting faster. I was still hard, and the sex scene was long over. I had to get rid of it, fast, before Jake thought this was because of him or something.

“But if I do it,” Jake said, a sultry purr to his tone, “then you have to take your shirt off, Katie. Fair’s fair.”

“Woah,” I heard John murmur. This was becoming a lot, ...