The Second Place Sister - Sex Stories

The Second Place Sister

... shook her head, “No, she doesn't really talk about that kind of stuff with me,” The sudden change in the direction of this conversation had Tim's cock swelling again. Stephanie was so close to him, and she smelled so good, and she looked just like Tori. Oh, geez, he was getting turned on by his girlfriend's sister. Not good! He needed to think of something else. He began chanting “grandma's apple pie” in his head, willing his erection to go down. It wasn't working, though. Stephanie shifted on the couch, and her bare leg rubbed against him. Her skirt rode up, and he could swear he saw her panties peeking out. She was like his fantasy version of Tori, all dolled up in sexy clothes. “Are you okay, Tim,” she asked, putting her hand on his arm. She was so warm. “Uh, yeah, I'm fine. It's just, well, I always kind of wished that Tori would dress like you do. She's really hot,” he laughed, “like you didn't know that. You just have to look in the mirror to see how pretty she is,” “She's beautiful,” Stephanie agreed, and snuggled in a little closer to him, “Maybe, well, this might sound crazy. Nevermind, I'm stupid,” She looked away, biting her lip. “What?” “Well, I just thought, maybe you could, um, you could kiss me? I mean, I look just like her, and so it wouldn't even really be cheating. Especially if it was just a kiss, right? Maybe it would make us both feel better. You can pretend I'm her, and I can be your pretend Tori, just this once,” Tim could no longer think of grandma's ...

... apple pie. His poor penis was so hard at the thought of what she was saying. The idea made some kind of sense to his hormone-controlled brain. They were identical twins, after all. It would be better than cheating on Tori by hooking up with some girl at a party or something, right? And he could trust Stephanie not to tell her about it, like some dumb girl might do bragging at school. Before he could say no, Stephanie's lips were touching his. Tim's balls were so blue he couldn't resist. Her lips were so plump and perfect, her gloss tasted like strawberry. He moaned as she pressed her mouth on his, her hand stroking his arm. He didn't even realize that he was putting his arm around her, his hand stroking her hair. She smelled so good! He opened his mouth, and felt her tongue slide inside, gently and passionately stroking his own. She moaned with desire as her hand slid off of his arm and onto his chest. His chiseled body felt wonderful to Stephanie, and she pushed him further by sliding her hand under his shirt. Their kissing became more passionate, and soon Tim was breathing hard. His cock was at full mast. Stephanie climbed onto his lap, straddling him, and took his face in her hands. Her tongue was so eager, not at all like Tori's tentative, cautious kisses. His hands slid under her skirt and rested on her perfect ass cheeks, gripping them firmly as her big tits mashed against his chest. He could feel her covered pussy humping against his cock, as it strained in his jeans. ...