She is the one - Chapter 19 from jashley13 - Sex Stories

She is the one - Chapter 19 from jashley13

... the way you’ve been acting—” “You know,” she said, cutting me off, “If you’ve had time to notice how I’ve been ‘acting’ around you, maybe you also noticed that Kayla and I are friends? Like, really close friends? So when I see you kissing someone else, and let’s just forget that it’s our cousin…my first thought is not, ‘well, hey, maybe I can use this to fuck him!’. Believe me.” “I didn’t want to kiss her,” I snarled, my anger coming back, “I thought she was Kayla! I woke up and there was a girl in bed and I just thought Kayla!” “Trust me, Jack, the look on your face…I knew you didn’t do it on purpose. Still disturbing to see.” My mouth dropped open. “You’re talking about disturbing to me? What about you and…” That was too mean. I immediately clammed up. Her mouth still curled into a snarl. “Next time I hit you, my hand will be closed,” she warned, “Watch you mouth.” I nodded. “God damn it, Jack, you and Kayla are in trouble and the first thing you think of is that I’m going to blackmail you?” “I thought you were.” “Regardless of what I want or how I feel, the last time I ‘tried something’ was before you two were even together. Remember?” I did. “You’re right.” “I know I am. So let’s just put aside any idea of me being a complete bitch, okay? Because that’s going to help no one.” “No one’s going to be helped,” I said quietly, glancing at my window, “It’s all over.” “You’re giving up that easy? Jack, it’s been a few hours.” “I told her it was an accident,” I growled, putting ...

... my head in my hands, “Why hasn’t she…” “Called you up to say she understands and all is forgiven? Gee, Jack, do you think maybe it’s because her boyfriend, whom she loves and adores, kissed another girl?” “On accident!” She sighed and paced. “Jack, all she’s thinking about right now is that your lips were on the lips of another girl. And not just another girl…Tara. How do you think that feels? Would you be ready to forgive her right away if she accidentally kissed Alan?” I snorted. “Would you?” “Fuck no. Alan wouldn’t be able to piss without screaming for a week. You didn’t answer my question.” I sat in silence for a bit, then said, “I can’t imagine her doing something like that. I just…can’t.” “It’s probably the same with her, Jack. She never imagined you would do something like that. So how hard do you think it is to know you did?” That was a sucker-punch to the stomach. I fought as hard as I could but the tears flowed out. I angrily swept the back of my hand against my eyes. No more crying, I snarled internally, trying my best to hold back sobs. My body shook and limbs quivered, barely holding back the tears that wanted so desperately to flow. Amanda’s expression softened a little. “You screwed up, Jack, but you did two things most guys wouldn’t do.” “What’s that?” “Fess up right away and actually stay away.” I swallowed a sob. “You wanted me to tell her.” “Of course I did! Honesty and all that stuff.” I nodded. “So how long do you think it’ll be before she…” She spread her ...