The Guessing Game - Part II - Sex Stories

The Guessing Game - Part II

... with us on the way here. It is your job to figure out which one it was.” She paced along the line of men, trailing her fingers along their firm stomachs. “You will be given ten minutes alone in this room with each of them, to conduct whatever sort of… research …you wish. You will have until midnight to inform me which one you believe was your mystery limo lover. Consider carefully, because if you guess incorrectly you will be teased and tortured by all of us at our discretion." "And if I win?" Kayla questioned. "We'll keep that a surprise." Melina smiled wickedly and winked. Kayla swallowed and felt anticipation growing in her gut again. Melina took Daphne’s hand and led her out of the room with the tall stranger who had brought them there. Scott and Ian followed. From the doorway, Melina paused, one of her hands already seeking out the bulge in the stranger's pants. “Your time with Lucas starts now.” She closed the door with a snap, leaving the two of them alone in the dim light. Kayla looked shyly at Lucas and walked across the room to stand in front of him, uncertain what to do next. He stood comfortably, waiting for her to do something. “How did you get convinced to play this…game?” she asked. Lucas just smiled and shook his head slightly. “You can’t talk?” He nodded. So there went her first idea on how to identify him. The man in the limo had whispered into her ear, but now she would never be able to try and identify his voice. That meant there was only one way she ...

... would be able to guess. Watching his eyes to make sure he didn't object, she reached for the buckle of his pants, fingers grazing past the bulge that was already growing. She didn't know why she was so nervous, considering all that she did on the ride here. Maybe it was because now she could see his face, and the hunger in his eyes. She successfully undid his pants and dropped them to the floor, pulling his boxers down after them. He stepped out of them with a flourish, and now it was more than just he that was standing at attention. Kayla eyed her specimen. It was long and hard, but then, weren't they all? She wouldn't be able to tell by looking, because she had never seen it in the first place. Feeling more bold, she reached out and grabbed his member firmly about the base, judging how well it filled her hand. Was this the right one? She couldn’t tell. She started to pump her fist up and down his length, watching his eyes close in pleasure. If she could just get him to groan, she would know. But as she continued, no sound escaped his lips, despite the fact that he was thrusting his hips forward eagerly into her hand. She glanced at the clock and saw that 5 minutes were already gone. Half of her precious time had already disappeared, and she still had no idea. Kayla sank to her knees in front of him and took him in her mouth, all the way to the back of her throat. As she sucked on him she slipped a hand between her own legs to where it was fast becoming wet again. Her fingers ...