Anal Anxiety (Part One) - Sex Stories

Anal Anxiety (Part One)

“You want me to do what?” I exclaimed, quite shocked at the idea. “Let me see if I heard you correctly. You want my husband and me to have anal sex at somebody’s home with people sitting around watching us?” “Well… in a manner of speaking… yes!” replied the owner of my favorite adult toy store. “You guys have become regular customers and have attended some of our in store demonstration classes, right?” “Yes, that’s correct,” I responded. “Well, we can’t do actual sexual demonstrations in the store. That’s why we just hold up a vibrator and describe how it works, or talk about different methods and all that,” Jen said. “But for some things, it really only works if you see it acted out. And, I know you have anal sex because we have talked about it. We have a number of mature customers who are really interested but unsure,” she continued, “so what better way than to have an experienced couple demonstrate?” My heart started beating quickly. “I don’t think I could do THAT or anything else in front of people sitting watching!” I blurted out. “I…” Jen interrupted me, “Look Cyndy, just think about it. You don’t have to answer me right away. After you think about it on your own, talk it over with your husband and see what he thinks. Then just let me know. No pressure, no worries,” she continued. “I just think you are the right guys to do this. I wouldn’t just ask anybody. Plus we would make sure it was a more mature audience. It would be by my personal invitation only.” “And,” she ...

... continued, “It’s not an orgy or anything like that. It is a group of mature couples who want to improve their relationships sexually. It is a fun night. We supply cocktails and some snacks.” Jen continued, “You can use and keep any toys or lubes that you need for the night from our store.” My mind was reeling. I had gone into the store to pick up some of the lubricant that I like, and here I was, getting asked to do anal in front of an audience. Now that was not what I had expected! Climbing into my car, I sat back and closed my eyes. Wanting my heart to stop racing before I started to drive, I imagined what it might be like to have sex while being watched. My first thought was to laugh it off as being totally ridiculous. Jimmy and me, at our ages… Even when I was nude at the resort on our honeymoon was a funny thought to me. This idea was just too silly. But then I thought of how much I enjoyed sex with Jimmy, and how wonderful our intimacy was. I pictured in my mind what it would look like, watching someone else have sex in front of me. That wasn’t a foreign idea. Then I thought of some of the adventures I had already experienced, including being on the bed with Jimmy and three of his friends, or being with Jake and his wife, or being with my brother-in-law and his wife. Even then, those were all different, and spontaneous… not a planned classroom event. I started reminiscing of the first couple of times I had anal sex. It was awkward, a bit painful and definitely needed some ...