Sisterhood of Sin -- 12 --The Caged Cock - Sex Stories

Sisterhood of Sin -- 12 --The Caged Cock

... and I knew that I got her off. When she stopped coming, she sat up and ordered me to straddle the bench. Then she leaned forward and started sucking my cock. I was so hard it didn't take long. I exploded into her mouth and she swallowed every drop. How was that for a story?" I was completely flabbergasted. "Dan, that really happened to you, didn't it?" "What? What makes you say that?" "You told that story in past tense, like it happened to you. Not in present tense, like you were imagining it. I know how hard it is to tell a true story in present tense. That sounded much more like a memory than a fantasy. It's true, isn't it? You told me you were a virgin, but you..." "I was a virgin. That doesn't make the story false. I still hadn't... Only my tongue. Okay, parts of it were true." "Parts of it?" "Okay, most of it." "That's better." "So do you want to hear the rest of the story then?" "Sure." "After she let me put my clothes back on, she told me that I had to confess my sins and that she would, too. Then we made a date to do it again after the next home game. We did it two more times after that. Then she went back to Notre Dame." "That's why you're such a good, uh, cunnilinguist." "Well thank you. I suppose she deserves some credit. She was my first." "Oh, my god, Dan. Look at your balls!" "Whoa. What the fuck?" "Looks like we have to ice them back down, you really enjoyed telling that story." "No, please. No more ice." "It's not like they're turning black, Dan. They're just ...

... a little blue. It's only ice water, not molten lava. You saw how puffed up and inflamed my pussy was last week. What kind of man are you going to be? The kind who goes the distance and earns respect for that? The kind who takes the punishment and earns respect for that? Or the kind who tries to weasel out of a challenge after I've completed it honorably?" "I'll take the punishment, Sister Cate. Just no more ice." "If you're accepting the punishment, Danny, just break the seal. I'm not breaking it for you." "Oh." He snips the zip tie with the nail clippers and then treats me to a few minutes of moans, groans, sighs, oohs, and ahs as he achieves relief from confinement after only about an hour of having his 'precious' in the cage. I think that maybe I should soothe his feelings, too. "I'm proud of you for getting into the spirit of this, Dan." I held up the smaller butt plug. "Would you like to insert this, or may I have the honor?" "You'll... be gentle, won't you, and use lubricant?" "Yes, Dear. I really don't want to hurt you. Up on the bed, down on your elbows." I pull a latex exam glove on. "Why are you doing that?" "Well, I think it will be easier on you to start with something smaller than this plug, and I don't want to scratch you with my fingernail." "Oh, Okay." I put the numbing lubricant on the tip of my middle finger, pry one of his cheeks to the side with the thumb of my other hand and rub the soothing gel around his puckered hole. I want to keep him engaged in the ...