Sarah's Submission: Ch 17 - Ali Loses Her Virginity - Sex Stories

Sarah's Submission: Ch 17 - Ali Loses Her Virginity

... FELONY, right? You stole over $1000. Stole! That means you go to prison for 18 months and pay a big fine. As well as have a felony on your record for the rest of your life. What were you thinking?”

Ali’s eyes got so huge and she broke down crying. “Please! Please don’t have me arrested! I’m sorry. I’m so so sorry! We didn’t think you would miss it. You had so much in your drawer. We didn’t think you would even notice!” she pleaded in between sobs.

“STOP that fucking crying right now!” he yelled. It shocked her and stifled her mostly. “I don’t see a ‘we’ in those videos. I see a ‘you’. You are the one stealing. All by yourself.” His tone a seething controlled anger. Not crazy or out of control, but clearly pissed. Sarah knew that exact tone only too well and shivered.

“But Sa…” she started and stopped herself. “I’ll give it back. I’ll give it all back. I’ll give you double. I could do that. I have money.”

Mr. Michaels played the next video. “I don’t want the fucking money back. You stole and you need to be punished. I like you, Ali. You seem like a decent person. But you stole and you must face the consequences of that bad decision.”

“You can’t do that! Please don’t. It will ruin my life. I’ll do anything. I’ll pay you back and babysit for free. From now on. Any time you want.” Sarah almost chuckled at how predictable this played out. It seemed to be a carbon copy of her night so far.

He stared at her for a long minute. Then played the next video of her and ...

... Sarah drinking before it jumped to Sarah spread open on the edge of the hot tub cumming loudly with Ali’s tongue licking her pussy. The scene looked like a professional porno.

Abject humiliation is the only way to describe Ali’s expression as her mouth dropped open. Mr. Michaels continued more calmly, “What am I supposed to do about that? I’m not going to be accused by your parents of condoning or even allowing this in my house. Underage drinking? And sex?”

“You CAN’T tell my parents. Oh my god! Please Mr. Michaels. You can’t do that! What would they say?!” Ali howled in panic with more tears rolling down her cheeks.

“Ali, I don’t want any of this. I don’t want to get you in trouble. But you have put me in a bad position. And you stole from me. This is all your doing. You are going to have to come to terms with the penalties for doing so.”

Ali looked at him and calmed herself. “Mr. Michaels. I will do anything. Please, can we just keep this between us. Please don’t have me arrested and tell my parents what I did.”

Mr. Michaels stayed quiet. Sarah could tell he simply waited to see what she wanted to offer as a bargain. But Ali just sat there. Pleading with her eyes as tears continuing to stream down her face. “I don’t see what else there is to talk about. You’ve given me no choice. I’ll have to notify the authorities and your parents tomorrow. It’s time to leave Ali.” Mr. Michaels stood and motioned for her to get up and leave. Sarah wrestled with the idea of ...