Coach’s Cutie Ch. 03 - Sex Stories

Coach’s Cutie Ch. 03

... (after giving him more of a real kiss): "I can't wait. See you there, Hon."

We both hop in our cars and head out. While I'm driving home, I can't help but think about Greg's comments about how he says he's not really that good of a guy, and the supposed things he's done. I mean, I had this thought initially when I was watching the game and I dismissed it, but maybe it really is possible that something has already happened between him and Madison?? I don't think Greg would be the type to deny it, so there's an easy way to get to the bottom of this.

Greg shows up about 15 minutes after I get home. We hangout and watch a little tv before deciding to call it a night. After brushing our teeth and getting into our pajamas, I decide to ask Greg point blank as we're climbing into bed.

Me (as Greg joins me under the covers): "So has something happened before between you and Maddie?"

Greg (looking genuinely surprised and confused): "Yeah, right... wait... are you being serious?"

Me (already pretty confident there's nothing he's hiding, but needing to clarify one more time just to be sure): "Yeah. Like has anything physical ever happened between you two?"

Greg (laughs): "Not at all. Like no way. I would never do that. But why would you even think that?"

Me (defensively now): "I don't know. Just based on how she was acting around you at the game, I guess?"

Greg (back to finding this more confusing than humorous): "Is this because of her hug at the end? I knew as ...

... soon as that happened that you were gonna make a big deal out of it. She was just really excited about the win. That's all, I swear."

Me: "It wasn't just that. It was the way she was looking at you and watching you all game long. I think she has a crush on you."

Greg gives me a skeptical look that says, 'yeah right'.

Me: "I'm serious. I mean is it really that hard to believe? Half the moms at the school wanna fuck you, so is it really that surprising if some of the students do, too?"

Greg (now seeming more relaxed with the direction our conversation is going): "I think there are a few moms at my school that are currently unhappy in their marriages, and they express their frustrations in some weird ways, sometimes."

Me (laughing): "Ha. That's a really diplomatic way of explaining that a bunch of horny moms wanna fuck the shit out of their kid's history teacher!"

We both laugh.

Me: "But seriously, it also was all this talk about how you're not actually a great guy, and there are things I don't know? What's that about? I thought maybe it was you trying to admit that something had actually happened."

Greg (looking down at the covers): "No, no, nothing like that. That was just..."

I feel like he's trying to confess something here, but isn't sure if he should? I have absolutely no idea what this could be. He's making me a little nervous, though. Could it actually be something legitimately bad?

Greg (looking right at me now): "The other night... last ...