Sibling Rivalry - Sex Stories

Sibling Rivalry

... Eric were in the living room and had heard everything. As soon as Cornelia realized what Penny was playing on her phone, they both got up and tried to escape outside undetected. But Joe saw them at the door, and he brushed Larry's shoulder and pointed at them. "Jailbreak!" he whispered.

"Cornelia!" Larry roared, jumping up.

"Daddy, it was just an April fool's joke that got a little out of hand!" Cornelia managed the cute smile that had always charmed him into submission before.

"You little bitch," Larry growled. "Just what do you have against me being happy again?"

"I...I..." Cornelia glared at Penny, who only gave her a triumphant look in response. "It was supposed to be family only!"

"And that's why you invited your boyfriend and his friend? And I let you! And then you lied about your sister saying exactly what you said?!"

"Well, what was she doing recording me? How paranoid are you, Penny?!"

"I'd say she had good reason to be paranoid!" Larry said. "As for you..." He looked back and forth at Eric and Cornelia. "I want you and Eric out of here. I'm going to take a walk and look for Jan, and you'd better be gone when I get back!" He all but tore the door off its hinges, and slammed it behind him.

After a moment of awkward silence, Penny said, "Can I help you pack?"

"Fuck you, you bitch!" Cornelia growled. "How could you do that to me? Weren't you the one who said 'we're sisters'?"

"Sisters who've known each other all our lives," Penny said. ...

... "So I knew you were probably going to pull something like this." She put an arm around Joe. "I'm only surprised I wasn't the victim this time."

Cornelia's smile returned. "Oh, but you are, Penny." She looked at Joe. "Are you going to tell her, or shall I?"

"Tell me what?" Penny's sense of triumph vanished, and she pulled back from Joe, who she saw also looked rather uncomfortable.

"I'll tell," Eric said. "And Penny, don't worry, it's good news for you."

"What?!" Both sisters said it, in very different tones of voice.

"Eric, man, I don't think you even know the whole story," Joe said.

"Oh yes I do," Eric declared. "I'm the only one who does. Penny, your sister wanted me to pull an April fool's trick on you, even before we found out Jan was coming here. She wanted me to introduce you to Joe and have you fall in love with him, and then reveal that he's engaged to this Italian chick."

"Carlotta?" Penny asked. "He told me about her."

"Yeah," Eric said. "What Neeli didn't know is, they broke up a few months ago because Carlotta cheated on him."

"You're making that up!" Cornelia screeched.

"No he isn't," Joe said. "That is what happened, but Eric, how did you know she cheated on me?"

Eric's face twisted into a sad smile, and he hung his head and stared at the floor.

"Oh my God." Joe clenched his fists and turned away from the others.

"Iknew there were others!" Cornelia shoved Eric into the wall, and slapped him and kneed him in the balls. "You ...