Sibling Rivalry - Sex Stories

Sibling Rivalry

... already has."

"Well, I meant..."

Jan put a finger to his lips. "Larry, I know what you meant. But tell me, why do you keep referring to both of the girls with anything negative when it's really just Cornelia? I know it's none of my business, but it's getting pretty hard to ignore."

"Well, Penny was always so easy to wind up. We always told her, if only she'd ignore Cornelia it'd stop, but she never listened.

"Oh, Larry."

"What?"

Jan shook her head. "Sorry. I shouldn't have said anything." She kissed him and rolled over. "Good night."

In the morning, Eric lingered behind the chimney for so long Penny turned off the water while he was still there. With a jolt Eric realized he might not have time to get back to Cornelia's room before Penny opened the bathroom door, and he concluded his best bet was to stay right where he was until Penny was back in her room. That, of course, did give him an excuse to watch as Penny patted herself dry, as well as to see her majestic bush dry for the first time. It was just as magnificent as he'd imagined and he knew he'd never lose his hard-on before he finally got back to Cornelia, but he didn't care. Hadn't she been the one to invite him to do this the first time? Watching Penny support each breast with one arm while drying under it with the other hand didn't do him any favors in that department either, but he enjoyed every last second of it.

As Penny turned out the bathroom light, a horrible thought occurred to Eric: ...

... what if she went to Cornelia's room and noticed he wasn't there? For three endless seconds he told himself she would never do that - didn't they both avoid talking to each other any more than they really had to?

On that at least, he was right. As he flattened himself against the chimney, he heard the wonderful sound of Penny's bare feet on the carpet as she returned straight to her own room. As soon as he heard the door shut, he crept out into the now-empty hallway and rushed back to Cornelia's room.

In the heat of the moment, Eric had forgotten he'd let his dick out of his shorts. He remembered when Cornelia looked up at him and burst out laughing. "Welcome back, both of you!" she squealed.

Eric looked down. "Oh my God..."

"You just remember which sister brought you here, right, Eric?"

"Yeah, of course, babe."

"Now put that away and let's go get some breakfast. We don't want to miss Joe getting here, do we?"

Lest she lose her nerve again, Penny put the blue bikini on and wore only a long t-shirt over it. As she headed up the stairs, she wondered if her father had found the cookie cutters he used to use for making pancakes on special occasions. The star was always her favorite, with the crispy points.

Arriving at the top of the stairs, she saw he had. "Two stars for you to start, Penny?" he asked.

"Oh, you remember!" Penny hugged him like the little girl she felt like for the moment, and took a seat at the table. "Yes, please."

"Your father didn't ...