Caught! - Sex Stories

Caught!

... now put some clothes on and we’ll do your makeup, you little tart,” I teased, giving the plug another good wiggle.

“Makeup, really?” Nathan shouted, spinning around and snatching up his teddy.

“Yes, really, I’ll be in the bathroom, when you’re ready,” I said, taking my makeup kit and suppressing a laugh at his excitement.

While my makeup skills still left something to be desired, I had perfected my smokey eye technique and was just finishing up when Nathan joined me. As expected, he looked wonderful in his teddy, stockings, and heels. With his flawless complexion, I didn’t think we needed to bother with the foundation and blending that my face required so I went straight to showing him how to properly enhance his eyes.

“So have you decided what your girl name is going to be?” I inquired as we worked.

“I was thinking maybe, Natalia or Nancy. What do you think?” he asked while trying to apply eyeliner without stabbing himself in the eye.

“I like Natalia, but you need to choose a name that suits the girl you want to be,” I answered, surprised at how quickly he was picking up the makeup techniques I was showing him. It had taken me months to learn what he was doing in just minutes.

“Natalia. I want to be Natalia,” he announced, reaching for the blush.

By the time Natalia finished applying her pink lipstick and I brushed out her hair, there was no trace of Nathan to be seen, just a beautiful young sex pot ready to be ravaged.

“Damn, I knew you’d be a ...

... gorgeous girl, but you’re absolutely stunning,” I exclaimed, looking Natalia over from head to toe.

Natalia twirled in front of the full-length mirror on the door, staring in awe at herself. “I’m so pretty,” she exclaimed, holding her hands to her pretty face. “Oh my God, Thank you so much for this,” she said, throwing her arms around me.

“It was my pleasure baby,” I said, holding her against my silicone-enhanced chest. She looked up with tears in her eyes and rose up to kiss me. “Don’t cry hun, we’ll have to redo your makeup,” I smiled, dabbing her eyes with a tissue. “Now there’s one more thing we need to do,” I added with a lust-filled grin.

“What’s that?” Natalia asked, her big brown eyes staring up at me.

“Turn around and lean over the vanity,” I smiled, showing her the bigger butt plug I’d been hiding from her.

A horny smile formed on Natalia’s cute face and she turned to stick her firm little bottom out for me. I took a moment to admire and caress her firm smooth cheeks before pulling her teddy aside and popping the plug already filling her ass in and out a few times. Natalia whimpered and pushed her ass out further as I teased her virgin hole. Tossing the smaller plug in the sink, I kissed her neck and pushed more lube into her tight little hole, before pressing the larger plug gently into her tight opening. With a little moan, Natalia wiggled her hips and I pushed the toy further in. I continued kissing and nibbling at her neck as I seated the larger toy ...