A Neighbor's Surprise - Sex Stories

A Neighbor's Surprise

... continued stroking me with one hand, and with the other began to rim around my rectum, softly at first, then gaining confidence, with increasing pressure. With her seeming innocense, I was amazed that she knew to do any of this. “How much did she really see of us?” I asked myself inwardly.

Toni placed her thumb firmly against my sphincter and started to push. “Apparently, she saw a lot!” I realized.

She had moistened her thumb with her saliva and slipped in me to the first knuckle easily. She continued to apply pressure and was soon buried as deeply as she could go. Sandy does this for me often, and I am used to the sensation. However, the fact that a seventeen-year old girl was diddling my ass was extremely erotic at the moment. Toni continued to stroke my cock with her free hand and was soon in sync with the rhythm I’d found with Sandy.

I ate her like there’d be no tomorrow, and she responded in kind; bucking and thrashing against me intently. Toni, novice though she were, was not shy about trying. She fucked at my tush with her thumb and continued jacking my cock. It would be a bit before I’d cum again, but Sandy hadn’t yet. I felt the tell-tale responses that always announce her climax as she crescendoed toward release.

“Humph, humph, aungh, . . . oh shhhhhiiiiiiiit,” she panted loudly as she came, finally pushing me away from her now sensitive, but very happy pussy. She noticed what Toni was up to, and motioned for her, “Come here Baby,” she said.

Toni ...

... pulled out and away from my backside, and knelt beside Sandy on the wide cushion. Sandy drew her into another passionate kiss and their breasts were soon pressed together beautifully. Sandy still had her legs drawn up and Toni beside her, had her’s beneath her. Her buns faced toward me and I could see her pussy lips between her cheeks, a rivulet of her honey dripping from her.

I knelt behind her on my knees and felt her heat as my prick touched her perineum. She reached behind her with one hand and grasped my throbbing pole to guide me home. I needed no further encouragement and began to press forward feeling the parting of her lips around me as my cock-head slipped insider her hot flesh. She was oh, so tight, and very, very wet. She was pushing back against me, and contracting her cunny-muscles. I gave her a moment to adjust and resumed my forward thrust. She and Sandy had broken their kissing and Toni had her head in the cusp of Sandy’s shoulder, her cheek against her breast. Toni now had both her arms around Sandy and was clinging to her tightly.

As I pushed, I met resistance that I knew was her maiden-head and paused, uncertain if I should go further. I couldn’t believe that she was a virgin after what we’d done together already. I looked at Sandy and searched her eyes for guidance. Realizing the situation, Sandy put her arms around Toni’s shoulders and mouthed to me, “Do it, Baby. Just be easy.”

Easy? It’s like breaking an egg; not hard to do, but you have to do ...