A Polaroid of Kristine, Part 5 - Sex Stories

A Polaroid of Kristine, Part 5

... something blunter to “have anal sex with you,” so I repeated myself a bit, enjoying the freedom of being able to talk dirty, “I was thinking about how it would feel to fuck you in the ass, and then I wondered what that might feel like, so I pressed a finger into my ass.” That last part was still hard to admit, but I wanted to tell her everything, and my heart pounded in my chest as I got the words out. Her reaction was immediate. She sat up with a start, pulling the dildo from her pussy, and she looked at me in surprise and shock. “You did what?!” she asked, looking at me sharply. Shit, I remember thinking, I shouldn’t have told her that. In that instant I imagined that she thought I was too weird, and that she wouldn’t want to have anything to do with me. My hand fell from my cock, and my erection started to deflate. “I… uh… I put a finger in my ass.” “Did it feel good?” she asked brightly and intently. Even though I was feeling relief at the way she asked the last question, which was full of curiosity and with no apparent negative judgment, all I could do was nod, my cheeks on fire. “Can you explain to me more why you did this, Michael? Had you ever done it before?” The words started to pour out of me. I had opened Pandora’s Box, and I needed to get it all out. “I was curious to see if it felt good, or if you were only going to do it to sort of to put up with it for me. I guess I thought it wasn’t fair for me to want to… fuck you in the ass, if I didn’t have an idea of what ...

... it felt like to be penetrated that way too.” Kristina had turned her head a bit sideways, and an eyebrow had come up as she listened to me. “You are a remarkable young man. I have encountered many men who have wanted anal sex, for all sorts of reasons, but I have never met one who was concerned about the ‘fairness’ of his desire.” She looked down at the dildo and smirked. “Perhaps I should penetrate you with this toy before allowing you to sodomize me, since we are speaking of ‘fairness.’” I gulped. Was she serious? The dildo was huge! Then again, it was smaller than my cock, and I was hoping to put that in her ass. I hesitated, but wound up saying in a small voice, “If you want to, then I’ll try.” Kristina looked genuinely startled at this, and she smiled thoughtfully. “No, Michael, I would not do that to you unless you really wanted it. This would not be an example of true fairness. After all, I want you to take me in the ass, and you want to do it. For me to fuck you with this toy for the sake of parity seems a bit silly. But I am impressed, and touched --I must say-- by your willingness to experience the same thing that you are asking of me. However, if you ever want me to do this to you, all you have to do is ask. I must admit you have piqued my curiosity.” I felt a sense of relief, though also of curiosity. My finger had felt good. What would something larger feel like? I looked down at the dildo thoughtfully, and then looked over at the brown paper bag again. “Did you ...