Boyfriend Sold Me on Craigslist - Sex Stories

Boyfriend Sold Me on Craigslist

I feel so stupid and disgusted right now. My boyfriend and I have been dating for a year and a half, we met right after I graduated high school and he was 20 at the time. I was just starting community college and was proud to have my own apartment for the first time ever (I have also worked around 30 hours a week since starting college so I support myself). He was older than me, but struggling. I guess prior to meeting me he had been pretty into d**gs, but I have never seen him do them so I really believed that was all over. And he was cute and sweet and I was kind of lonely, most of my friends having moved much farther away for college. Anyways, we got together and he moved in with me shortly after because he was always struggling with money despite having a pretty good job at a landscaping place. Plus, it was fun to play house and have someone to come home to after all my LONG days going to classes and then working. We had a really great sex life. Well, I thought it was great. We were both kind of kinky and after about six months we decided to try a threesome with two guys. It was really hot. I loved having two guys give me all their attention, it made me feel wanted and sexy. Our sex life was better just the two of us afterwards so we ended up doing this once or twice a month until now. My boyfriend would always find the guy “through friends” which never felt suspicious because, why would it be? We just hung out and I could have stopped if I didn’t like the guy. I trusted ...

... my boyfriend and I never felt unsafe. This came crashing down the other night. I should tell you that sometimes my boyfriend’s “fantasy” changes where he’ll start to hang out with me and the other guy like normal, but then he just wants to watch while we fuck. Okay, sure. But sometimes he even goes home and wants me to spend the night at the guys house which is kind of weird, but still, I thought it was just kink. Well, this happened the other night and my boyfriend went home and I slept with the guy and it was really good. We ended up having a great connection. So much so that we spent most of the night talking in bed. This guy says “I know you don’t like to talk about this, but I just want to say this wasn’t weird at all and I think you’re a really cool person.” “What?” “Oh sorry, your boyfriend said it turns you off to talk about this, I just wanted to give you a compliment.” “What are you talking about?” Silence. I knew something was very wrong here. I had certainly talked to my boyfriend about my turn-offs but they were along the likes of potty play… nothing about conversation topics. I felt sick. Something was up. In hindsight, I wish I would have just gotten over it and left it alone. But I did what all women do, I pried. It turns out he didn’t know my boyfriend through mutual friends. They had never even met before that night. Only emailed. BECAUSE MY BOYFRIEND PUT AN AD FOR ME ON CRAIGSLIST. Yup. This hookup (and god only knows how many of the others) was a result of ...