My Daughter 5 - Sex Stories

My Daughter 5

... day." "What do you mean?" "Well, let's just say that Riley, much like you, wanted some experience before finally having sex with you." "So you fucked Riley?" "Yep." "Does mom and Beth know?" "Yes, your mom knows, I told her over the phone when you all were on the way back. And Bethany not only knows, but encouraged it. The only rule was that Riley couldn't do anything with me that Bethany hadn't already done." Letting that sink in for a moment, I paused and chugged about half my beer. By this point I noticed that Mark was unconsciously stroking his cock through is athletic shorts. I was starting to get hard, too, and decided that I would stroke my own through my mesh shorts. "Wait.... you mean.... did you say that Riley could only do with you what Bethany had already done?" "Yes, you heard me correctly." I told him. "So you've fucked Bethany, too?" "Yes, and to answer your next question, your mom knows. And with both of them, it was some of the best sex I have ever had! Oh, and one more thing, Bethany and Riley have the same kind of agreement with you. Riley gets you first, but Bethany wants to fuck you too. Bethany can only go as far with you as Riley has." By this point, neither of us were hiding the fact that we were stroking our cocks through our shorts. I was reflecting on the events of the past few days with the girls, and the past several months of blow jobs from my daughter. I could tell that he was thinking about all of the possibilities, having fucked one of the ...

... three women in the house, and now knowing the other two wanted to fuck him as well. We spent the next several minutes talking about everything. I filled him in on the promise I had made to Bethany when she was 16. I told him about the morning that I first messed with both of the girls, and about the nightly blow jobs from his sister. At the next lull in the conversation, Mark handed me another beer and opened one for himself and started a new conversation. "Dad, I have a question..." "Go ahead." I told him in an encouraging voice. "Well, you know that Bethany and I have remained 'free' around each other, hanging out naked whenever you and mom went to bed. Even though neither of us have ever acted on anything, or even mentioned it, I can tell that there was more than a brother/sister feeling there. And since I have been home I have found myself thinking more romantically about her. And then there's Riley. I have always had a crush on her, and when I heard that she wanted to fuck me, I was more than excited, but also a bit scared. I feel like I am falling for her, too. Obviously my mind is wracked with emotions towards mom, too. I mean I was so turned on by her, but when we made love, and when we've kissed sense, it's been something different. I guess my question is, is it ok, to love each of them?" "Mark, buddy, of course it is. Don't get me wrong, my love for your mother runs very deep. And I love your sister as my daughter. But recently, especially with everything that has ...